Save Bathgate Green Belt
#3Save green belt area's.
Patricia Atkin (Tillicoultry , 2022-10-14)
#4We must protect our precious green space and we must respect local democracy
John Ogden (Bo'ness , 2022-10-14)
#5I believe in this cause
David Aiton (Kinross, 2022-10-14)
#14Too much land is being appropriated for housing. A number of flats in Bathgate are being demolished for rebuilding into flats and there is something similar happening near Livingston. Leave this precious ground alone.
Susan Vickerman (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#15Fed up of all the houses being built and the green belt being eaten up with it no wonder there is a decline in certain animal species greedy property developers
Debbie gunn (West Calder, 2022-10-15)
#31I grew up in falside. Played in that area for years. Took dog walks there.. believe there's no need to destroy that natural area for houses when there's plenty other places to do it
Katrina Fraser (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#35I originally objected to the plan nothing has changed.
Brian Lavery (Armadale, 2022-10-15)
#40we must protect natural green belts and not allow petty officials to destroy them at their whim. follow the money
david colman (bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#41I'm digning as I oppose to the desecration of green belt land and wanton destruction of ancient trees and wildlife. In addition there are insufficient community services to support this development. Traffic, Doctors, Schools and pharmacies are already bursting at the seems.
Alex Fleming (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#43I object to the destruction of this special area where nature flourishes.
There are protected species present who will be further endangered of their habitat is removed.
Rosslyn Barr (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#44Local democracy rules surely over some anonymous person with no local knowledge
Tom CLARK (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#47As a resident in Bathgate I feel not only is there no infrastructure for more houses in Bathgate the said development is in the green belt which hosts varied wild life
Elaine Flannigan (Bathgate West Lothian , 2022-10-15)
#48The use of the Scottish Reporter to overrule local councils and take away greenbelt is scandalous.
Chris Horne (Linlithgow , 2022-10-15)
#53I am signing because this decision is ultimately a wrong and dangerous one. Firstly because of the environmental destruction and secondly because of increase in traffic on a road that is already swamped with cars coming from the many new built estates in Armadale. Bathgate does not need more detached houses with a possible minimum of 2 vehicles + work vans entering on to an already busy road!
May Dunsmore (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#54I value the green space around our town and the flora and fauna in it. I also object to the rejection of the public appeals.
Lisa Lumsden (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#56This is a protected site.
Paul Henderson (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#57Permission for this had been denied and should not have been overruled, this is essentially green space and belongs that way not for housing
Bernard Gallacher (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#59To build on and destroy acres of land in a green belt, to destroy protected species and ancient trees is absolutely disgraceful and downright disgusting. The green belt is there for a good reason, to protect our land... Bathgate is struggling with the population influx already and is steadily getting worse, with no regard to the lack of resources to accomodate the people that live here. What is being done here is absolutely to line someones pockets, pure greed and totally no thought to anything or anyone else. This is 2022, we should be looking after our planet, not destroying it for pure profit!!!
Laura Weir (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#60We need to preserve more green space in Bathgate, far too much housing development as it is without the expansion though of local services to cope with the influx of people to Bathgate. We need more things like schools and doctors surgeries not more housing
Benjamin Gallacher (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#65I’m signing this because I want Bathgate,s nature and environment to be protected for the good wellbeing of our community and for all who come after.
Bernard Mcilwaine (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#66I care about the green belt
Janet lee (Boghall. Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#67It is an utter disgrace and an environmental disaster that this is being allowed to happen. What about the legal obligation to protect our vulnerable wild life and green spaces. I am beyong angry at this.
Margaret Ann Boyle (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#70We must protect democracy and respect the wishes of the local community
Ian McGregor (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#72It’s green belt.
Elaine MacLennan (Livingston , 2022-10-15)
#73Reporter needs to stop overriding local democrat y.
Malcolm McGeachy (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#74I am concerned about the abuse of green belt in West Lothian
Sally Hopkinson (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#75Being from Bathgate I strongly disagree with the consent that has been granted for new house development in the Falside area of Bathgate. The town has no capacity for more housing and the green fields should be kept that way .
David Heatlie (Glasgow , 2022-10-15)
#77Apart from losing one of the few remaining green areas in the town, the road system nearby is not made for that many more vehicles. Also the local school would be oversubscribed.
So many people against this, especially the local government planners, yet one person gets to override their decisions. Not right!
Susan Scott (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#79Enough with taking away our protected green land so someone makes a fortune in backhanders.
Enough of not listening to people who live here.
Enough of one faceless person riding roughshod over a democratic vote!!
Brian Watson (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#82I agree with Harry and this bit of green belt in Bathgate needs to be preserved
Andrew Craise (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#83I agree with Harry Cartmill that this important green belt area in Bathgate should be preserved
Helen Craise (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#86We must save our Green Belt
Terry Barrett (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#94The community do not want the land developed. There will be an environmental impact as well as an impact on community services which are already stretched.
gordon mcmillan (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#96The overturn of this unanimous decision is an absolute disgrace.
Claire Rafferty (Armadale, Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#97There are rare species of wildlife in this area. I am trying my best to help our environment, I have seen kids from the local primary school over to get interested in wildlife. Is today’s society all about greedy fat cats making a fast buck for themselves and no consideration for the kids of today.
William Weir (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#100As a former resident of the area under discussion, I know first hand the detrimental effect that this will have on the environment , infrastructure and amenities for the residents of Falside and Windyknowe.
The decision to grant planning permission has no sound logic behind it and is not wanted by the majority. It should be overturned.
Steven Rosie (Falkirk, 2022-10-15)
#101We need to save our green belt for our children and nature
Use brown belt first
West Lothian council rejected this
Alice Mc Nulty (Harthill, 2022-10-15)
#102The protection of the environment and surrounding green belt area should be paramount
Charles Mackenzie (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#104There are a limited number of green spaces our town can enjoy and the Scottish Government's decision to obliterate a habitat with such diverse wildlife, flora and fauna is a disgrace. Shame on you!
Rob Thornton (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#107Our schools, nurseries and doctors cannot sustain more households. This piece of land has always and should always be where Boghall ends.
Manda Drummond (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#109The local area can't cope with another 200 houses in this location. The SG needs to reconsider its decision as it will only bring problems to Bathgate.
Graham McLauchlan (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#112There are too many homes being built without thought for the infrastructure (GPs already at bursting point, schools full etc) or the environment
Linsay Logan (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#113I’m signing because nature has to balance - are there any plans for Carbon Capture? No didn’t think so.
Dylan Hampshire (Strathaven , 2022-10-15)
#114As a local resident I enjoy and appreciate the local flora and fauna on my doorstep. There are plenty of brownfield sites that could do with welcome redevelopment instead of spoiling what little accessible greenery we have left
David Curliss (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#116I strongly object to the destruction of our community and the hazardous effects of this potential housing estate.
Sam Rennie (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#117Moved away from the City, to be in Bathgate for peace and to live the quiet life. Bathgate doesn't really need 100 odd brand new properties.
Kevin McGaff (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#118I oppose the building of house on green belt in our area.
Nicola Graham (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#120I care about protecting wildlife and environment of the local area, and Scotland as a whole. We should not be destroying these areas to line the pockets of property developers, nor overriding the wishes of the local people on the matter.
Carrie Boardman (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#121The land around Bathgate is beautiful......we need to keep this.
Alice McKay (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#123This estate not only will destroy an environmental area but it will also put a strain on services that are already inadequate
Amanda Campbell (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#125I care about the small amount of green space we have left and the wildlife.
Pamela Donaldson (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#128I don’t agree with the future housing development plans
Elizabeth Marr (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#129It’s where I spent my childhood
Alison Ann Fenwick (Hamilton , 2022-10-15)
#131Im originally from Bathgate and this levelling of protected green belt is disgraceful
Moira Jackson (Livingston, 2022-10-15)
#134The unnecessary destruction of
green belt land without the support the local community. Financial gain is the main priority ,with no consideration for the local environment.
Ian Rutherford (Falkirk, 2022-10-15)
#135I'm against losing our green belt
William Hynds (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#139I'm unhappy that so many people have opposed this housing proposal but they are being ignored.
Lorna McOwat (Bathgate , 2022-10-15)
#140I think these decisions destroy democracy.
Tony Boyle (Livingston, 2022-10-15)
#142We have to protect animals habitat
Jill Robertson (Haddington , 2022-10-15)
#144People need green spaces and the Central Belt of Scotland is being overdeveloped massively and unsustainably.
M D (Cupar , 2022-10-15)
#145This will ruin the environment in this area as well as cause schools and GPs to be oversubscribed
Nicholas Salerno (Bathgate, 2022-10-15)
#150I was brought up in Bathgate and hate seeing the erosion of the local communities’ democracy!
Reid John (Westbury, 2022-10-15)
#155It's important to protect wildlife and save green belt areas from destruction. Also the heath centres in Bathgate are already struggling to cope with numbers of patients in our area.
Jacquelyn Christie (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)
#158Absolutely disgusting, leave our land alone
Irene Martin (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)
#167This area has a natural open area with greenery and wildlife, also to build here would e a traffic safety hazard given the location.
Lynne Waddell (Bathgate , 2022-10-16)
#169I think our local health care & education departments cannot cope with an influx of new residents. The roads certainly don’t need any more traffic & the drainage system simply will not be able to cope. It is very important to keep our green belt without building more houses.
Anne Bannan (Bathgate , 2022-10-16)
#1711. It's a complete disgrace that decisions are made in full knowledge that it will wipe out already endangered species.
2. Why is an unelected person able to make these crucial decisions when it's clearly against the will of the local people in the community.
3. The infrastructure is not there to support this sudden rise in the population, the extra schools, roads, medical support is just not in place and it will cause major problems in the bathgate area.
Andy McKay (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)
#172It’s critical that this doesn’t become the norm! We have to keep the green belt to protect the true nature of the town. The town itself doesn’t have the infrastructure to support all the extra people that building more houses will bring. Schools are full, roads are way too busy , can’t get kids into clubs cos they are already full!
Dee Bell (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)
#182Why does this one single nonentity have the power to overturn the democratic vote with no possible recourse!! It's scandalous
He's probably got a bulging back pocket though!!
Stewart Reid (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)
#185The environment should be protected. Enough of these new housing developments
Andrew Todman (Macmerry, 2022-10-16)
#186I live in Falside and was part of the numerous campaigns to block this development. Twice rejected by council and not wanted by residents. Now the say so of one planning person our beautiful area will become a sprawl of houses with insufficient infistruture to cope.
Sarah McLachlan (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)
#187This is an area of natural beauty and too many of are green belts are being destroyed by greedy housing developers
Rose Drummond (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)
#190The concept of the green belt was first introduced back in 1935 as a special land designation wrapping around the urban areas in the UK in order to protect the sense of openness in the natural context. Without this strict guidance, it was predicted that high levels of urban sprawl would dominate the natural context; with new developments consuming all available land as the population rapidly grows. The green belt acts as a protective barrier to this - reducing people's ability to build on the surrounding rural areas, thereby ensuring the continued protection of biodiversity and forest lands. That is why this housing development must be stopped and this area of natural importance be preserved for future generations of the Bathgate community. If not then Bathgate's urban sprawl will co-join with Armadale and an important natural widlife corridor will be lost.
Andrew Baird (BATHGATE, 2022-10-16)
#192Green Space is important as there soon be no place for our wildlife to live.
Billy Bishop Bishop (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)
#194There needs to be green spaces. The infrastructure of schools and medical services need to be able to support the communities around them.
Diane Samuel (Bathgate , 2022-10-16)
#200I don’t agree that one person (reporter) can overturn a decision from an elected assembly.
Robert Flannigan (Bathgate, 2022-10-16)